Current:Home > StocksWhy Wisconsin Republicans are talking about impeaching a new state Supreme Court justice-LoTradeCoin
Why Wisconsin Republicans are talking about impeaching a new state Supreme Court justice
View Date:2024-12-23 23:45:24
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin’s Republican-controlled Legislature is talking about impeaching a newly elected liberal state Supreme Court justice even before she has heard a case.
The unprecedented attempt to impeach and remove Justice Janet Protasiewicz from office comes as the court is being asked to throw out legislative electoral maps drawn by the Republican-controlled Legislature in 2011 that cemented the party’s majorities, which now stand at 65-34 in the Assembly and a 22-11 supermajority in the Senate.
Here is a closer look at where things stand:
HOW DID THE STATE GET HERE?
Protasiewicz won election in April to a 10-year term on the Wisconsin Supreme Court beginning Aug. 1. Her 11-point victory gave liberals a 4-3 majority, ending a 15-year run with conservatives in control.
During her first week in office, two lawsuits were filed by Democratic-friendly groups and law firms seeking to overturn Republican-drawn legislative maps.
WHY IS THERE TALK OF IMPEACHMENT?
Republican lawmakers who have talked about the possibility, most notably Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, allege Protasiewicz has prejudged redistricting cases pending before the Supreme Court because of comments she made during her campaign. They also argue her acceptance of nearly $10 million from the Wisconsin Democratic Party disqualifies her.
The state Democratic Party is not part of either redistricting lawsuit, but supports the efforts.
The court has yet to say whether it will hear the redistricting challenges. Protasiewicz also has yet to say whether she will step aside in the cases, including the decision on whether to hear them.
If she does step aside, the court would be divided 3-3 between liberal and conservative justices. However, conservative Justice Brian Hagedorn has sided with liberals on major cases in the past, angering Republicans.
WHAT EXACTLY DID PROTASIEWICZ SAY?
Protasiewicz frequently spoke about redistricting during the campaign, calling the current Republican-friendly maps “unfair” and “rigged.”
“Let’s be clear here,” she said at a January forum. “The maps are rigged here, bottom line.”
“They do not reflect people in this state,” Protasiewicz said at the same forum. “I don’t think you could sell any reasonable person that the maps are fair. I can’t tell you what I would do on a particular case, but I can tell you my values, and the maps are wrong.”
She never promised to rule one way or another.
WHAT DOES THE LAW SAY ABOUT RECUSAL AND IMPEACHMENT?
On recusal, the U.S. Constitution’s due process clause says a judge must recuse if they have a financial interest in the case, or if there is a strong possibility of bias.
There are also state rules laying out when a judge must step aside from a case. Those generally include any time their impartiality on a case can be called into question, such as having a personal bias toward one of those suing, having a financial interest or making statements as a candidate that “commits, or appears to commit” the judge to ruling one way or another.
On impeachment, the Wisconsin Constitution limits the reasons to impeach a sitting officeholder to corrupt conduct in office or the commission or a crime or misdemeanor.
HAS A WISCONSIN SUPREME COURT JUSTICE EVER BEEN IMPEACHED?
The Wisconsin Legislature has voted only once to impeach a state judge who was alleged to have accepted bribes and heard cases in which he had financial interests. It happened in 1853, just five years after statehood, and the state Senate did not convict.
HOW WOULD SHE BE IMPEACHED?
It takes a majority vote in the Assembly to impeach and a two-thirds majority, or 22 votes, in the Senate to convict. Republicans have enough votes in both chambers to impeach and convict Protasiewicz.
If the Assembly impeached her, Protasiewicz would be barred from any duties as a justice until the Senate acted. That could effectively stop her from voting on redistricting without removing her from office and creating a vacancy that Democratic Gov. Tony Evers would fill.
Vos, the Assembly speaker, has said he is still researching impeachment and has not committed to moving ahead.
The day after Protasiewicz was elected, Wisconsin Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu seemed to cast doubt on the Senate proceeding with impeachment.
“To impeach someone, they would need to do something very serious,” LeMahieu told WISN-TV. “We are not looking to start the impeachment process as a regular occurring event in Wisconsin.”
WHEN COULD THIS GET CLEARED UP?
The court is under no deadline to decide whether it will hear the redistricting challenges. Likewise, Protasiewicz doesn’t have a deadline for deciding whether she will recuse herself. Both decisions could come at any point.
If the court decides to hear the challenges, it would then set a timeline for arguments. It is unclear when, if Protasiewicz remains on the case, the Legislature might proceed with impeachment proceedings.
veryGood! (77885)
Related
- Amazon Best Books of 2024 revealed: Top 10 span genres but all 'make you feel deeply'
- You Can't Miss Emma Stone's Ecstatic Reaction After Losing to Lily Gladstone at the 2024 SAG Awards
- Why do we leap day? We remind you (so you can forget for another 4 years)
- Stock market today: Asian shares mostly decline, while Tokyo again touches a record high
- LSU student arrested over threats to governor who wanted a tiger at college football games
- South Carolina voter exit polls show how Trump won state's 2024 Republican primary
- Suspect arrested in murder of student on Kentucky college campus
- 'Oppenheimer' looks at the building of the bomb, and its lingering fallout
- New York nursing home operator accused of neglect settles with state for $45M
- Barbra Streisand Will Make You Believe in Movie Magic with SAG Life Achievement Speech
Ranking
- Artem Chigvintsev Returns to Dancing With the Stars Ballroom Amid Nikki Garcia Divorce
- The next sports power couple? Livvy Dunne's boyfriend Paul Skenes is top MLB prospect
- What recession? Professional forecasters raise expectations for US economy in 2024
- Inside the SAG Awards: A mostly celebratory mood for 1st show since historic strike
- Utah AD Mark Harlan rips officials following loss to BYU, claims game was 'stolen from us'
- Man found guilty in trans woman's killing after first federal gender-based hate crime trial
- 2024 SAG Awards: Josh Hartnett Turns Attention to Oppenheimer Costars During Rare Interview
- Flint council member known for outbursts and activism in city water crisis dies
Recommendation
-
Quincy Jones laid to rest at private family funeral in Los Angeles
-
Love Is Blind’s Jimmy Defends His Comment About Not Wanting to Have Sex With Chelsea
-
From 'The Holdovers' to 'Past Lives,' track your Oscar movie watching with our checklist
-
‘The Bear,’ ‘Spider-Verse’ among the early winners at Producers Guild awards
-
Taylor Swift Politely Corrects Security’s Etiquette at Travis Kelce’s Chiefs Game
-
This is what happens when a wind farm comes to a coal town
-
Kings beat Clippers 123-107 behind Fox and hand LA back-to-back losses for 1st time since December
-
Lithium ion battery caused fatal fire in New York City apartment building, officials say